Teaching · Free PDF

What Communion Is NOT

Clearing Up Nine Major Misunderstandings

By Pastor Nicole Washington

1 Corinthians 11 · Matthew 11:28·12 min read

Over the years, I've heard so many misconceptions about Communion.

People tell me they feel disqualified. They tell me they don't understand what's happening. They tell me they're afraid they're doing it wrong.

And my heart breaks, because these misunderstandings are keeping people away from one of the most powerful spiritual practices available to them.

So I want to take some time to clear up nine major misunderstandings about Communion. Not by arguing about theology. But by going back to Scripture and asking: what does the Bible actually say Communion is?

And by contrast, what is it NOT?

Sometimes, what Communion is not is just as important as what it is.

Misunderstanding #1

"Communion Is Just a Ritual"

What People Think

Some people believe Communion is just a ritual. A tradition. Something we do because we've always done it. They think: 'It's nice, but it's just symbolism. It doesn't really do anything.'

For every time you eat this bread and drink this cup, you are announcing the Lord's death until he comes again.

— 1 Corinthians 11:26 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

Communion is far more than a ritual. You're not just going through the motions. You're making a proclamation. You're announcing something crucial to the universe.

Jesus also said, "I am the living bread that came down from heaven. Anyone who eats this bread will live forever; and this bread, which I will offer so the world may live, is my very flesh" (John 6:51, NLT). That's not just symbolism. That's a spiritual reality that has eternal consequences.

Communion is not a ritual to perform. It's an encounter to experience. It's a spiritual reality that transforms you.

Misunderstanding #2

"Communion Is Magical"

What People Think

Some people think Communion is magical. Like, if they receive it, their specific problem will disappear. Their sickness will be healed. Their money will appear. They think: 'If I just receive Communion with the right attitude, God will grant my wish.'

What the Bible Actually Says

Communion is not magical. Magic is when you perform a ritual and get a guaranteed outcome. That's not what Communion is. Communion is relational, not transactional.

You don't receive Communion to get something from Jesus. You receive Communion to encounter Jesus. Sometimes, in that encounter, healing happens. Sometimes provision comes. Sometimes peace appears. But not because you performed the right ritual. It happens because you encountered the living Jesus, and He chose to move on your behalf.

Communion is not: "I do this, and God is obligated to do that." Communion is: "I come to Jesus, and I encounter His presence, and I trust Him with the outcome." Jesus is not a vending machine. He's a relationship.

Misunderstanding #3

"Communion Is Condemnation"

What People Think

Some people think Communion is a place of judgment. They read the passage: 'Examine yourself before eating the bread and drinking the cup' (1 Corinthians 11:28). And they think: 'I'm not good enough. I'm not pure enough. If I receive Communion, God will condemn me.'

Come to me, all of you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest.

— Matthew 11:28 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

Communion is not condemnation. It's grace. When Paul says "examine yourself," he doesn't mean: "Be perfect before you come." He means: "Be aware. Know what you're doing. Come with sincerity." The examination is not to disqualify you. It's to help you come fully, with your whole heart.

Not: "Come if you're good enough." But: "Come. All of you. Weary. Burdened. That's who I'm calling." Communion is an invitation to the weary and broken, not a judgment of the perfect.

Misunderstanding #4

"I'm Disqualified Because I Sinned Recently"

What People Think

People think: 'I sinned this week. I'm not ready to receive Communion. I need to clean myself up first.' They think Communion is only for people who have their act together.

If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.

— 1 John 1:9 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

If you're a sinner, Communion is for you. All of us are sinners. If you've never sinned since your last Communion, there's a problem — and it's not that you're too good for Communion.

Confess your sin. Right then. Before you receive Communion. Confess it to Jesus. Ask for forgiveness. And then receive Communion. The point is not to be sinless. The point is to be honest. Confession clears the air between you and Jesus. Then come to His table. Receive His grace. Be reminded that you're forgiven. That's what Communion is for — people who mess up and need Jesus's grace.

Misunderstanding #5

"Communion Is Earning God's Favor"

What People Think

Some people think: 'If I receive Communion regularly, God will like me better. I'll earn His favor. I'll be more blessed.' They treat Communion like a spiritual credit card. Swipe it enough times and you'll cash in a blessing.

God saved you by his grace when you believed. And you can't take credit for this; it is a gift from God. Salvation is not a reward for the good things we have done, so none of us can boast about it.

— Ephesians 2:8-9 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

Grace is not earned. It's received. You don't earn God's favor through Communion or anything else. God's favor is a gift. Communion is not a transaction. It's not earning points with God. Communion is receiving what Jesus has already purchased for you. It's accepting a gift that's already been given. You don't have to earn it. It's yours because Jesus paid for it.

Misunderstanding #6

"Communion Is a Replacement for Faith"

What People Think

Some people think: 'If I just receive Communion, I don't really need faith. The ritual itself will do something for me.' They think faith is optional if you do Communion.

And it is impossible to please God without faith. Anyone who wants to come to him must believe that God exists and that he rewards those who sincerely seek him.

— Hebrews 11:6 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

Communion is not a replacement for faith. It's an expression of faith. You need faith to receive Communion meaningfully. Communion without faith is just eating bread and drinking juice. There's nothing spiritual happening. But Communion with faith — that's transformation. Communion is not the source of faith. It's the practice that grows faith.

Misunderstanding #7

"Communion Is Only for Certain Denominations"

What People Think

Some people think Communion is only for Catholics, or only for Protestants, or only for a particular denomination. They think: 'I'm not part of that church, so Communion isn't for me.'

When we bless the cup at the Lord's Table, aren't we sharing in the blood of Christ? And when we break the bread, aren't we sharing in the body of Christ? Though we are many, we all eat from one loaf of bread, showing that we are one body.

— 1 Corinthians 10:16-17 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

Communion is for all believers. Not: "Baptist believers share in the body of Christ." But: "We share in the body of Christ." All of us. Every believer. Every denomination. Every tradition. Communion is not owned by any denomination. It belongs to the whole body of Christ.

Misunderstanding #8

"Communion Is Only for Church"

What People Think

Some people think Communion is only valid in a church setting, with a pastor leading. They think: 'It's too sacred to do at home. It's too formal to do alone.'

For where two or three gather together as my followers, I am there among them.

— Matthew 18:20 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

Communion can happen anywhere. Jesus doesn't say: "Where two or three gather in a church building." He says: "Where two or three gather." That includes your home. That includes your hospital room. That includes a nursing home. That includes anywhere believers gather in Jesus's name.

The early church "met in homes for the breaking of bread" (Acts 2:46). Not in fancy church buildings. In regular homes. Jesus is not limited to church buildings. His presence is not confined to official worship spaces. Communion at home is just as valid as Communion in church.

Misunderstanding #9

"Communion Is Only for Perfect People"

What People Think

Some people think Communion is only for really spiritual people. People who pray a lot. People who read their Bible daily. People who have their lives together. They think: 'I'm not spiritual enough. I'm not good enough. Communion is for better Christians than me.'

Come to me, all of you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest.

— Matthew 11:28 (NLT)

What the Bible Actually Says

Communion is for broken people. Not: "Come to me, all of you who are perfect." But: "Come to me, all of you who are weary and burdened." That's most of us. Most of us are weary. Most of us are carrying burdens.

You don't have to be perfect. You don't have to be super-spiritual. You just have to be sincere. Come as you are. Jesus will meet you there.

Part Two: What Communion Actually IS

Now that we've cleared up what Communion is NOT, let me remind you what Communion actually IS.

Communion Is An Invitation

Jesus invites you to His table. Not just the spiritually elite. You.

Communion Is Remembrance

You're remembering what Jesus did. Not just as history, but as something that affects you personally, right now.

Communion Is Encounter

You're meeting the living Jesus. Not just thinking about Him from a distance. Actually encountering His presence.

Communion Is Nourishment

Your spirit is being fed. Spiritually sustained. Strengthened for the journey ahead.

Communion Is Worship

You're expressing your love for Jesus. Your gratitude. Your surrender. Your faith.

Communion Is Covenant

You're renewed in your agreement with Jesus. Your commitment to Him. Your belonging to His kingdom.

Communion Is Grace

You're receiving what you don't deserve. Forgiveness you didn't earn. Love you can't deserve.

Communion Is Love

Jesus is saying: 'I died for you. I love you. I want to be in relationship with you.'

Part Three: Questions People Ask

Can Children Receive Communion?

This varies by church tradition. The key is: do they understand that this is about Jesus? Do they come with sincerity? If yes, children can receive Communion. Jesus didn't exclude children.

Can Non-Believers Receive Communion?

Communion is for believers — people who've made a commitment to Jesus. But if someone is genuinely seeking Jesus, genuinely wanting to understand, they can receive Communion as a way of encountering Jesus.

What If I'm Struggling With My Faith?

Receive Communion. Struggling believers need Jesus just as much as confident believers.

What If I Have Doubts?

Come to Communion with your doubts. Jesus can handle your doubts. Communion might actually strengthen your faith in the midst of doubt.

What If I Don't Feel Anything?

That's okay. Communion is about truth, not feelings. Feelings come and go. Truth remains.

How Often Should I Receive?

That's between you and Jesus. Listen to the Holy Spirit. Follow what draws you closer to Him.

Part Four: Foundations for Receiving Communion Rightly

Come With Honesty

Don't pretend. Don't hide. Come as you are.

Come With Faith

Believe that Jesus is present. Believe that He cares about you. Believe that this encounter matters.

Come With Gratitude

Thank Jesus for what He did. Thank Him for this invitation. Thank Him for His presence.

Come With Openness

Let Jesus speak to your heart. Be willing to be changed. Be willing to receive what He's offering.

Come With Sincerity

You don't need fancy words. You don't need to be eloquent. Just be real. Just be sincere.

Reflection Questions

Which misunderstanding about Communion resonates most with you? Which one have you believed?

How does understanding what Communion is NOT change how you think about Communion?

Which truth about what Communion actually IS speaks most powerfully to your heart?

What's been holding you back from receiving Communion? Is it one of these nine misunderstandings?

How would your approach to Communion change if you fully believed what Scripture says about it?

Have you ever received Communion and felt some of these misunderstandings operating in your heart?

What would it look like for you to receive Communion with honesty, faith, gratitude, openness, and sincerity?

Is there someone in your life who's been disqualified by these misunderstandings? How could you help them understand the truth?

How can you prepare your heart to receive Communion rightly, freed from these misunderstandings?

What's one step you want to take this week to move closer to a right understanding of Communion?

Closing Prayer

Jesus, I'm learning what Communion is not.

Help me to let go of the misunderstandings I've been carrying. Help me to release the shame, the disqualification, the fear that's been keeping me away.

Help me to understand that Communion is an invitation, not a judgment. That it's grace, not condemnation. That it's for me, not against me.

Help me to receive Communion rightly. With honesty about where I am. With faith in who You are. With gratitude for what You've done.

Help me to know that I'm welcome at Your table. That I belong there. That You want me there.

Jesus, I'm ready to receive Communion with a new understanding. A truer understanding. A Scripture-based understanding. Thank You for clearing up my confusion. Thank You for inviting me to Your table. Thank You for loving me this much.

In Jesus' name, Amen.

Declarations

I declare: Communion is not just a ritual. It's a living encounter with Jesus.

I declare: Communion is not magical, but it's powerful.

I declare: Communion is not condemnation. It's grace.

I declare: I am not disqualified from Communion because I've sinned.

I declare: I cannot earn God's favor through Communion. But I can receive it.

I declare: Communion is not a replacement for faith. It's the practice that builds faith.

I declare: Communion is for all believers, not just certain denominations.

I declare: Communion is valid anywhere — church, home, hospital, wherever I meet Jesus.

I declare: Communion is for broken people, weary people, struggling people like me.

I declare: I am invited to Jesus's table, and I accept that invitation.

I declare: I will receive Communion rightly, with honesty, faith, gratitude, openness, and sincerity.

Final Words

Communion is not what you might have thought.

It's not a ritual you perform perfectly. It's not a magical transaction. It's not condemnation or judgment. It's not earning favor. It's not limiting. It's not exclusive.

Communion is an invitation.

An invitation to encounter the living Jesus. To be nourished spiritually. To be reminded that you're loved. To be welcomed at His table.

You are welcome there.

Whatever you've been told. Whatever you've believed. Whatever's been holding you back. You are absolutely, completely, unconditionally welcome at Jesus's table.

Your Next Step